When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more here.

Hiking Boots vs Shoes: What’s The Difference?

Ever stood at the crossroads (or, ya know, the outdoor store aisle) pondering the age-old debate: hiking boots or shoes?

It’s like choosing between a deep-dish and thin crust – both have their merits, but it’s all about the vibe you’re going for.

As someone who’s clocked more miles on trails than your car’s odometer, I’ve got some dirt on the pros and cons of each.

So whether you’re aiming to conquer Everest or just the local nature trail, let’s break down the foot-facts and help you step out in style and comfort.

Understanding Hiking Footwear

guy looking at hiking shoes

When it comes to hiking, choosing the right footwear is essential for a comfortable and safe experience.

In this section, we’ll discuss various types of hiking footwear to consider: Hiking Boots, Hiking Shoes, Trail Runners, Approach Shoes, and Sandals.

Hiking Boots

Hiking boots provide excellent support, traction, and protection for your feet, especially when traversing rough terrain or carrying a heavy load.

Their high ankle support can prevent injuries, and the solid construction offers improved durability.

However, hiking boots tend to be heavier and less flexible compared to other types of hiking footwear, which might lead to increased fatigue during longer hikes.

  • Pros: Ankle support, stability, durability, and protection
  • Cons: Heavier, less breathable, and less flexible
Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Shoe
$99.95 $76.40
  • ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY: Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot features our lightweight, durable midsole for long lasting comfort, superior cushioning, and high energy return as well as an advanced traction rubber sole for slip-free movement on rough ground.
  • HANDY FEATURES: Treacherous days out on the trail are comfortable and worry-free with this boot's waterproof full-grain leather and mesh bootie construction and its durable mesh tongue for breathability.
  • ADJUSTABLE FEATURES: The Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot features a lace-up closure for an adjustable, secure fit.
  • OMNI-GRIP: This multi-terrain traction system matches specially formulated compounds and treads to specific environments. A dual-zone winter tread pattern ensures solid footing on surfaces such as ice and snow.
  • SURE FOOTED:Responsive, supportive cushioning and super-grippy rubber outsoles are geared for miles over rocks, grass, gravel, and roots.
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 04:32 pm GMT
Columbia Women's Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped Hiking Boot
$100.00 $79.99
  • ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY: The Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped Hiking Boot features a seam-sealed construction, combined with our TECHLITE lightweight midsole, for long-lasting comfort with superior cushioning and high energy return.
  • DURABLE HIKING BOOT: This women's boot is inspired by classic mountaineering style. A durable mid cut waterproof hiker that provides great traction and comfort. This classic Columbia hiking boot, will deliver years of comfortable service.
  • ALL TERRAIN TRACTION: Our signature Omni-GRIP non-marking traction rubber outsole provides high grip across a wide variety of terrain, and versatile three season use.
  • HANDY FEATURES: Treacherous days out on the trail are comfortable and worry-free with this hiking boot's waterproof combination of supportive leather and suede construction.
  • REINFORCED TOE AND HEEL CONSTRUCTION: Designed for extended years of use, we’ve reinforced the toe and heel barriers, and extended the outsole toe overwrap to guard these key wear points.
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 05:07 pm GMT

Hiking Shoes

Hiking shoes are a more lightweight option compared to hiking boots, offering greater flexibility and breathability while still providing support and traction.

They are ideal for day hikes or well-groomed trails where ankle support is less critical.

However, they may not provide adequate protection on rugged terrain or during more demanding treks.

  • Pros: Lightweight, flexible, and breathable
  • Cons: Less ankle support and protection
Merrell Men's Moab 3 Hiking Shoe
$120.00 $49.99
  • Pigskin leather and mesh upper, 100% recycled laces and webbing
  • Bellows tongue keeps out debris, Protective toe cap 100% recycled mesh lining
  • Kinetic Fit ADVANCED removable contoured insole with reinforced heel cushioning for medium support
  • Molded nylon arch shank, Merrell Air Cushion in the heel absorbs shock and adds stability
  • Lightweight EVA foam midsole for stability and comfort Vibram TC5+ rubber sole
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 04:12 pm GMT

Trail Runners

Trail runners are designed specifically for trail running and offer a lightweight, flexible, and breathable option for fast-paced hiking.

They often feature a grippy sole for improved traction but may lack the support and protection of hiking boots or shoes.

Trail runners are best suited for well-maintained trails and those confident in their footwork and balance.

  • Pros: Lightweight, flexible, and breathable
  • Cons: Limited support and protection
ALTRA Women's Lone Peak 7 Trail Running Shoe
$149.95 $95.72
  •  RUNNER'S WORLD 2023 AWARD WINNER: Best Trail Shoe
  • Stay Focused: With our MaxTrac outsole and multi-directional TrailClaw lug pattern for grippy traction, you can focus on the trail infront of you
  • Go Further: Balanced Cushioning platform places the heel and forefoot the same distance from the ground, which encourages low-impact landings
  • Run Naturally: Our FootShape toe box allows the toes to relax and spread out naturally
  • Get Comfortable: Highly responsive and comfortable Altra EGO midsoles provide the support needed for high intensity trail day
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 03:21 pm GMT

Approach Shoes

Approach shoes are a versatile option for hikers who venture into both hiking trails and more technical climbing areas.

They offer a balance between the flexibility of a hiking shoe and the grip of a climbing shoe, making them suitable for scrambling and light climbing.

Approach shoes typically have a durable and protective construction, but they might not be the most comfortable for longer hikes.

  • Pros: Versatility, grip, and protection
  • Cons: Less comfortable for extended hikes
KEEN Men's Jasper Low Height Climbing Approach Style Sneakers
$78.09
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 11:37 am GMT

Sandals

Hiking sandals can be a great option for those venturing into warm or wet environments, as they offer excellent breathability and quick drainage.

With durable soles and adjustable straps, they provide a comfortable and secure fit.

However, they lack the support, protection, and insulation of other hiking footwear options, making them unsuitable for rough terrain or cooler conditions.

  • Pros: Lightweight, breathable, and quick-drying
  • Cons: Limited support, protection, and insulation
KEEN Men's Newport Closed Toe Leather Sandals
$98.00
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 11:46 am GMT

By understanding the various types of hiking footwear available, you can make an informed decision to select the most suitable option for your hiking adventures.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Hiking Footwear

hiking boots from back

Weight

When selecting hiking footwear, consider the weight of the shoes or boots.

Lighter options like trail runners may be more comfortable for long distances, while heavier boots provide more support and protection.

Remember that a lighter shoe will help you feel less fatigued during your hike, but it may compromise durability.

Durability

The lifespan of your hiking footwear will depend on the construction, materials used, and how often you hike.

Hiking shoes may need replacement after roughly 500 to 750 miles of use, while boots can last longer.

It’s essential to invest in footwear that can withstand rugged terrain and frequent use.

Comfort

Comfort is crucial when choosing hiking footwear, as it can make or break your hiking experience.

Make sure your shoes or boots fit well and don’t cause blisters.

Look for cushioning and support features, such as a moderate heel drop and well-padded insoles.

Also, consider the break-in period, as some footwear may require time to soften and mold to your foot.

Waterproofing

Waterproof hiking footwear can keep your feet dry in wet conditions, but it may not be necessary for every hiker.

Shoes with waterproof membranes like Gore-Tex are great for wet environments, but they can be less breathable.

If you mainly hike in dry areas, opt for non-waterproof options that provide better breathability.

Breathability

Breathable hiking footwear keeps your feet cool and dry, preventing bad odors and blisters.

Look for materials that allow air to circulate, like mesh panels and moisture-wicking fabrics.

Keep in mind that waterproof shoes are usually less breathable than their non-waterproof counterparts due to the waterproof membrane.

Traction

Good traction is essential for navigating various terrains and staying safe on inclines or slippery surfaces.

Look for hiking footwear with grippy rubber outsoles and deep, well-spaced lugs that can provide traction on wet and dry grounds.

Shoes with aggressive tread patterns are suitable for muddy or rocky trails.

Stability

Stability features help prevent ankle roll and ensure stable footing on uneven surfaces.

Choose hiking shoes or boots with a firm midsole and a stable heel counter for proper support.

If you’re a beginner hiker, opt for a model with some stability features to build confidence and hone your skills on the trail.

Footwear Features and Technology

hiking boot sole separation

Shoe Uppers

The upper part of hiking footwear plays a crucial role in comfort, durability, and protection.

Uppers are often made of lightweight materials like synthetic mesh or leather to provide breathability and resistance to abrasion.

Some shoes also feature waterproof membranes, like Gore-Tex, to keep your feet dry in wet conditions.

Remember that the choice of upper material can impact the overall weight and breathability of your footwear.

Midsoles and Cushioning

Midsoles are essential for providing cushioning and shock absorption.

They are typically made from EVA (ethylene vinyl acetate) or PU (polyurethane).

EVA midsoles tend to be more lightweight and provide better cushioning but might wear down faster.

In contrast, PU midsoles are denser, offer more support, and have a longer-lasting durability.

Some hiking shoes also incorporate a rock plate for additional protection against sharp rocks and uneven terrain.

Protection and Support

When choosing between hiking shoes and boots, consider the level of protection and support you require.

Hiking shoes usually have reinforced toe boxes and lower-cut designs, which provide ample protection and flexibility for moderate terrain.

Meanwhile, traditional hiking boots offer greater ankle support, ideal for more challenging or extended hikes.

Remember that a good fit is crucial in finding the balance between support and comfort.

Grip and Traction Technology

Grip and traction are vital for all hiking footwear.

Look for outsoles made from durable and slip-resistant materials, like Vibram, which are widely recognized for their traction on various surfaces.

The lug pattern on the outsole also plays a part in providing grip.

Deep, widely spaced lugs offer better traction on muddy and loose terrain, while shallow, closely spaced lugs provide more surface contact for better grip on rocky trails.

Choosing Footwear According to Hiking Conditions

Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Shoe
$99.95 $76.40
  • ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY: Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot features our lightweight, durable midsole for long lasting comfort, superior cushioning, and high energy return as well as an advanced traction rubber sole for slip-free movement on rough ground.
  • HANDY FEATURES: Treacherous days out on the trail are comfortable and worry-free with this boot's waterproof full-grain leather and mesh bootie construction and its durable mesh tongue for breathability.
  • ADJUSTABLE FEATURES: The Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot features a lace-up closure for an adjustable, secure fit.
  • OMNI-GRIP: This multi-terrain traction system matches specially formulated compounds and treads to specific environments. A dual-zone winter tread pattern ensures solid footing on surfaces such as ice and snow.
  • SURE FOOTED:Responsive, supportive cushioning and super-grippy rubber outsoles are geared for miles over rocks, grass, gravel, and roots.
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 04:32 pm GMT
Columbia Women's Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped Hiking Boot
$100.00 $79.99
  • ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY: The Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped Hiking Boot features a seam-sealed construction, combined with our TECHLITE lightweight midsole, for long-lasting comfort with superior cushioning and high energy return.
  • DURABLE HIKING BOOT: This women's boot is inspired by classic mountaineering style. A durable mid cut waterproof hiker that provides great traction and comfort. This classic Columbia hiking boot, will deliver years of comfortable service.
  • ALL TERRAIN TRACTION: Our signature Omni-GRIP non-marking traction rubber outsole provides high grip across a wide variety of terrain, and versatile three season use.
  • HANDY FEATURES: Treacherous days out on the trail are comfortable and worry-free with this hiking boot's waterproof combination of supportive leather and suede construction.
  • REINFORCED TOE AND HEEL CONSTRUCTION: Designed for extended years of use, we’ve reinforced the toe and heel barriers, and extended the outsole toe overwrap to guard these key wear points.
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 05:07 pm GMT

Summer and Moderate Hiking

During summer and moderate hiking conditions, you can opt for lighter footwear like hiking shoes or trail runners.

These shoes offer more breathability, and their lightweight nature allows you to cover greater distances with less fatigue.

They are usually sufficient for well-established trails without too many hazards.

In muddy conditions, however, make sure the shoes you choose have good traction to prevent slipping.

Winter Hiking and Heavy Loads

When you’re winter hiking or carrying a heavy backpack, it’s essential to choose appropriate footwear.

Winter conditions often involve snow, ice, and freezing temperatures, making insulated and waterproof hiking boots a necessity.

These boots provide better support and stability for heavy loads, ensuring your safety and comfort on the trail.

Besides, they offer better ankle protection to prevent injuries from trail hazards such as rocks or roots. Remember, winter hiking requires footwear that:

  • Is insulated and waterproof
  • Provides good traction on snow and ice
  • Offers ankle support and protection

Rugged and Rough Terrain

In rugged and rough terrain, specific footwear considerations should be taken into account.

Hiking boots are usually the preferred choice as they give more ankle support and protection against potential injuries from rocks, roots, or even snake bites.

Sturdy, high-cut boots help you maintain a stable footing and minimize the chances of ankle twists and sprains.

When hiking on rough terrain, look for boots with:

  • Robust construction and durable materials
  • Good traction on various surfaces
  • Ankle support and protection from trail hazards

Special Considerations for Hiking Footwear

KEEN Men's Targhee 3 Mid Height Waterproof Hiking Boots
$165.00 $98.50
  • WATERPROOF: KEEN.DRY waterproof breathable membrane keeps your feet dry and comfortable all day long by allowing vapor out without letting water in
  • TRACTION: KEEN ALL-TERRAIN rubber outsole provides high traction grip in muddy environments and on rocky surfaces; Non marking rubber outsoles leaves no trace or imprints when walking indoors
  • SUPPORT: External Support Shank and mid cut height adds ankle support and balance on uneven surfaces; Contoured heel provides next level stability
  • FIT: Mid profile upper for comfort and secure fit with padded tongue and collar
  • COMFORT: Removable metatomical footbed design provides excellent arch support and cradles to the natural contours of the foot
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 04:25 pm GMT

Fit and Comfort

When it comes to hiking footwear, proper fit and comfort are essential for an enjoyable experience.

To find the perfect fit, try on your hiking shoes or boots with the socks you plan to wear while hiking, such as wool socks for added insulation and moisture-wicking.

Ensure there is enough room in the toe box, and they feel comfortable when worn for an extended period.

Hazards Protection

Outdoor trails can be unpredictable. Hiking boots with a higher cut provide better protection against hazards like rocks, roots, and snake bites.

Conversely, lightweight hiking shoes offer less protection but are more suited for less challenging terrains, such as day hiking on well-defined paths.

Backpacking and Multi-Day Hikes

For multi-day hikes or heavy backpacking, a supportive and durable boot is essential.

Although heavier than hiking shoes, leather hiking boots provide the necessary stability and support for your ankles and feet.

Hiking shoes may lack sufficient ankle support, which could lead to additional wear and tear over time.

Mesh and Synthetic Materials

Hiking shoes often use mesh and synthetic materials for breathability and a lower weight.

The lighter construction makes them ideal for day hiking trips.

However, they may not be as durable as leather hiking boots and are more susceptible to wear and tear from rough terrain or heavy use.

Leather Hiking Boots

Leather hiking boots are known for their durability and protection.

They require a longer break-in period to achieve out-of-the-box comfort but offer excellent support, especially for multi-day hikes or backpacking.

Although heavier than synthetic materials, the leather provides long-lasting performance and resilience against harsh conditions.

KEEN Women's Targhee 3 Mid Height Waterproof Hiking Boots
$175.00 $89.95
  • WATERPROOF: KEEN.DRY waterproof breathable membrane keeps your feet dry and comfortable all day long by allowing vapor out without letting water in
  • TRACTION: KEEN ALL-TERRAIN rubber outsole provides high traction grip in muddy environments and on rocky surfaces; Non marking rubber outsoles leaves no trace or imprints when walking indoors
  • SUPPORT: External Support Shank and mid cut height adds ankle support and balance on uneven surfaces; Contoured heel provides next level stability
Buy at Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/29/2023 03:03 pm GMT

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between hiking boots and hiking shoes?

Hiking boots typically provide more ankle support and offer better protection against the elements due to their higher cut and more robust materials.

Hiking shoes, on the other hand, are usually lighter and more flexible, making them a better choice for shorter hikes or less demanding terrain.

While both are designed for outdoor activities, you should choose based on your personal needs and the type of hiking you plan to do.

How do hiking shoes perform compared to trail runners?

Hiking shoes are designed specifically for navigating trails and uneven terrain with features such as more aggressive tread patterns and better foot protection compared to trail runners.

While trail runners are lighter and often more breathable, they might not be suitable for more challenging hiking situations.

When choosing between hiking shoes and trail runners, consider factors such as the nature of the terrain, weather conditions, and your level of experience.

Which is better for long hikes: boots or shoes?

For long hikes, hiking boots might be a better option due to their increased support, durability, and protection.

However, this depends on individual preference and the nature of the hike.

If the hike involves varied terrain with potential obstacles or weather changes, hiking boots are recommended.

If the trail is well-maintained and the weather is stable, hiking shoes might suffice, especially if you prioritize lighter weight and breathability.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of hiking boots?

Hiking boots have several advantages, including increased ankle support, better protection from the elements, and enhanced durability.

They are generally better suited for longer hikes and more challenging terrain.

Disadvantages include their heavier weight and reduced breathability compared to hiking shoes.

They might also require a longer break-in period before they feel comfortable.

Ultimately, the decision between hiking boots and shoes depends on personal preference and the type of hiking you plan to do.

How do women’s hiking shoes differ from men’s?

Women’s hiking shoes typically differ from men’s in terms of fit and overall design.

This is because women’s feet generally have a different shape, with a narrower heel and a higher arch compared to men’s feet.

As a result, women’s hiking shoes are designed with these differences in mind, providing a more comfortable and secure fit for female hikers.

When selecting hiking footwear, prioritize finding a pair that fits your specific needs and provides the best support and comfort for your feet.

Sharing is caring!